Monday, January 20, 2020

News on Triple Grotto! - Orangutan Update - 1.13.20

I came across this photo recently and wanted to share it. Since this post is about Triple Grotto, I thought I'd do so here.  Taken by me many years ago.  I have always love it and cherished its perfect capture of Our four Precious long-timers, Cobby, Tallulah, Maggie and Minnie.  Enjoying the sun in South Grotto.  I Love them.

Before I report what the update is, I want to say a few things. ... If you want to skip to the update, scroll down to highlighted paragraph.  I hope that even if you do, that you will read the entire post, as I always put alot of time and energy into writing a well illustrated post.

I got this update on Monday.  Since then I have been trying to decide how to write this post.  The main thing was whether or not to name who I got it from.  This person is not someone who I talk to in confidence, so that is not the reason.  Regardless of whether in confidence or not, I don't want anyone who talks to me, to be vulnerable to any wrath.  So, I decided not to use a name.

After my blog post How Long Will The Orangutans Live in the Skytrails? dated 9.29.19  I started weekly updates, that included blog posts and videos, regarding the situation.  The first week in December was the eight month mark that the Orangutans had been at the Zoo and still had no proper home.  It had been the full eight months since the male had been anywhere except the bedrooms and trails.  In that same eight months, the female had access to the yard for seven weeks.  For those seven weeks, the Chimps were locked inside, with no outdoor access or fresh air, for the whole Summer.  None of my social media efforts seem to be making a difference in shaming Zoo Director Tanya Peterson to do the right thing and move forward with creating a space in Triple Grotto for the Orangutans.  

At that point, I thought, enough of this crap.  What is going on?  Why is this being allowed to happen?  I sent an email to the AZA President Dan Ashe, the Orangutan SSP Chair Lori Perkins, and Orangutan Studbook Keeper Megan Elder.  I never expect to get responses, and I didn't, but I wanted the people responsible for sending these poor Animals to a place that has no proper home for them to know what was going on (if they didn't already), and that someone is watching and documenting this crime.  After eleven days, I sent the same message via Facebook Messenger to the AZA and the SSP.  The gist of the message was a repeat of my emails, Do you know...?  Maybe they did and didn't care, maybe they bought the illusion that there was or would be a place for them in the new Great Ape Passage.  Hard to believe that any professional would think rotating them through the Dayroom and Yard with an eventual Troop of seven Chimpanzees, was a feasible option, which I have illustrated many times it is not.   My message included a link to one of my shaming videos. ... Three days later the Orangutans had access to the yard.  Two days after that, there were people in Triple Grotto.  I'm not assuming my correspondence is connected to those events, but I'm not one who believes in coincidence.

That said, if there was a connection to my correspondence and something happening at this time, its disgraceful that a member of the public has to go to these lengths to get something done, when the Director who pulls in a hefty salary, is getting paid to ensure the right thing is being done for the welfare of the Animals in the Zoo's Collection and those being Acquired.

Week before last, was four weeks since the Triple Grotto sighting, I still had not seen any sign of anything happening.  I decided enough waiting, I want an official word in regard to the situation.  We all deserve to know what's going on. 

This past Monday, I saw an upper management staffer who I talk to.  I approached and asked specifically, "What's the time frame on a space in Triple Grotto for the Orangutans?"  My question was met with, "We're working on it."  I said, "Well they have been here for eight months and should have had something before they got here, but we are way past that now."   The instance of them going to the yard three times a week, was quickly put forth, to which I noted that has only been happening for the past few weeks.

There was more discussed, mostly the same that I write about here in posts.  I will note about some of it in later paragraphs, but for the purpose of getting to the point, the update, the main take-away is this,...

There will be a renovation to the North Grotto.  There will be no netting!?  The only topical information I was given was that the exisiting bridge between the bedroom building and the island, would be removed and replaced.  I have no other information about what the renovation will include.  The design team from MK Think who did the Snow Leopard and Madagascar designs is working on it.  I was given a timeline of two months.  I don't know whether that is done in two or starting in two.  I would have to think the later.  

Before I go any further, I want to say a few things.  Thank you to this person for the information.   I always appreciate the conversation.  I have known this person for years, and even though our views are different, and I know this person does not like what I write in this blog, but it seems it has never been held against me.  I approach with questions as a member of the public and should be treated with the same courtesy, regardless of my personal opinions and what forum I share them.  I value a healthy discussion and rational dialog, something other people there could take note to learn.  I hope that continues, as I will say, that I will continue to believe what I believe based on what I see with my own eyes, what I learn about situations (both from my own research and outreach), and what my conscience tells me.   

That said, I want to bat about some things from the conversation.  I didn't get into a debate about these things in conversation because the purpose was to find out when a space would be created, not to enter into a debate knowing we each believe what we believe.  Contrary to what some think, my opinion is just that.  I write the posts to document information, and in addition to facts, I use my opinion to support the issue.  My opinion, is not meant to tell anyone what to think.  The facts stand for themselves.  I was told in this conversation, that I write negative things.  I answered, "Yea but they're true."     

My comment that there should have been a space for the Orangutans before they got here, was addressed.  The reasons given were repeated a few times.  It was noted that the male, until recently was not recalling.  It was noted that it took time to introduce the two. ... I personally don't see the relevance of either reasoning.  Regardless of personality and procedure, when an Animal is acquired, there should be a proper home for it at that time, or upon the completion of quarantine.  Regarding the issue of the male's recall.  Yes I heard that was a concern, if he had went into yard earlier (when female had access).   My understanding was that is because at the time it was a shared yard. If this was their own yard, if he wanted to stay out all night, so be it.  He went out to the trails and stays there all night.  My personal opinion that I've expressed in previous posts, is that he knows his name, so because there were circumstances with his transfer (on both sides) that could have caused him to not be happy with the situation and therefore be stubborn about recalling. In regard to introductions.  As I remember, they were introduced soon after they arrived.  Getting them to interact favorably may have come later, but in my opinion has no bearing on there being a proper home for them.  If there was a yard that they could have had daily access to straight out of quarantine, their interaction may have even progressed quicker.  The Zoo is lucky that the male took refuge in the trail for months.  The Zoo really would have had a problem if they had two active Orangutans stuck in the trails.

Another reason given, that I heard, funding.  Again, this is something I've already written about.  The Zoo Director and Society, have wanted to bring in Orangutans for at least five years.  This was the catalyst for Director Peterson trying to kick out our Senior Chimpanzees in 2015.  So at minimum, they have had five years to raise funds for creating a space in Triple Grotto.  The two spaces created in the first phases of the Great Ape Passage, the Dayroom and Yard, were created for the Chimps.  A third space in Triple Grotto is needed for the Orangutans, and to make the whole exhibit, including trails, complete.  That is the only feasible way to rotate the two species, so both have daily outdoor access. 
The Yellow Loop shows the area the Great Ape Passage is supposed to encompass.  
I left it open ended at Middle Grotto since that seems to not be part of the current plan.
Screencaps from Google Satellite Map
Seemingly taken during first phase of construction.

I'm going to continue on talking about Triple Grotto.  Already noted was the confirmation that the third space will be renovated in North Grotto only.  I have given my opinion in many posts about what I think is the best and logical thing to happen there, and doing just North Grotto and doing it first isn't it.  That said, obviously, in that regard all I can do is fantasize.  If you haven't read my opinion before, its basically, first do South Grotto.  Net it over, and be done with it for now.  Just to give them immediate access.  Then, take the time to do a permanent space right.  In my opinion any space created should compliment the two new spaces, as it is an extension of them in finishing the Great Ape Passage.  Its also my opinion that the North and Middle Grotto should be combined by filling in the moats.  The grotto islands are not enough topical space.  In the photo, I have circled the island and the outer circle.  When the Chimps lived in Triple Grotto, they had access to all three islands and it still wasn't enough.  When in North Grotto, they sat like literal bumps on a log, on that structure, because there was no place else for them to go.  I hope that is not all that's planned for the Orangutans.  It sure won't be a space that seven Chimpanzees can rotate into.  I sure hope the renovation somehow extends the topical space, but without netting, I don't see how that can happen.  Without that happening, I don't see how much renovating can be done to North Grotto, and frankly fear the Orangutans will be pretty much living in North Grotto as is.  This would be sad, and feel like a quick fix to a pressing problem.  Hope I'm wrong.  I still think filling in the North Grotto moat is essential at some point.  Regardless of what happens now or in the future, expanding the topical space of North Grotto has to happen.


That all repeated, I actually have a new idea.  With all the rain we have been having, in addition to the popularity of the Dayroom, my new idea is creating more indoor spaces.  With the news that only North Grotto will be renovated, there would be space for my new idea, which would be in the space of Middle Grotto.  It would take filling in the moat and netting.  Creating an indoor viewing area for visitors that is an extension of North Grotto.  Initial thought, something covered, like at Sifaka, but with the animal side enclosed like a mini-dayroom, but that opens out into the Grotto.  So not two separate spaces, but something that even during bad weather both the animals and visitors can be sheltered, while not sacrificing any topical space.

So, to wrap-up, I am glad to have an Official word on what is going on with Triple Grotto.  No matter what is done, the goal is to get the Orangutans daily access to a yard as soon as possible.  

I still maintain that there should have been a third space created before the Orangutans got here, or at least soon after.  The Orangutans have lived all to most of eight months in a caged tube.  The Chimpanzees suffered seven weeks without fresh air and outside access to a yard created for them.  At this point, the efforts are all just too late.   The damage has been done.  When the space is done, there will be no redemption, just relief.

*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*



Tuesday, January 7, 2020

Will the Orangutans Get a Home by their Anniversary?

Today will be three weeks since the Orangutans started having access to the yard.  From what I can figure, they get to go out twice a week.  So, over 21 days, they have been out of the caged tube approximately 6 times.

I haven't uploaded photos from my SD cards in quite a while, so this is a picture taken off the back of my camera from New Year's Eve when I saw them out in the yard.

When I wrote my last update about them going out,  I didn't write much of what I saw and my thoughts. I thought I'd wait, as I expected to see something else by now, but there has been nothing.  No maintenance to the area at all.  No paint prep for the night quarter building.  No NOTHING.  So, this means, there will apparently be no third area created anytime soon so the Orangutans can have daily access to a yard.  As they head into their nine month as Residents of the San Francisco Zoo, they still have no proper home.

Video I took yesterday.

A note about what I saw at Triple Grotto on 12.19.19  As I stood watching the Orangutans, I heard non-zoo staff inside the exhibit talking about measurements and one of them came out into the long trail and took photos toward the night quarter building. For me if attention was only paid to North Grotto, that does not seem to be the quickest way to get the Orangutans into a yard, unless its going to be a quick build just to get them out.  That would be curious, as there has been nothing quick about resolving this issue, or about what's best for the Orangutans.

As I've written, ideally South Grotto would be netted over immediately, so they have access to a yard now.  Then they can continue to take their time renovating an area in North and Middle Grotto that will compare in style to the dayroom and yard and complete the Great Ape Passage.  Anything less, in my opinion will be something they slap together just to get it done.  Then they can move on to other projects I hear are in the works, like the alleged plan to ship out our Tucker the Hippo, in favor of expanding the Black Rhino area.  THIS is another disgraceful plan in my opinion.  More on that another time.

So, as it usually goes I'm sure there are people on staff who will get their panties in a twist about what I've documented, but that's not my problem.  I write the truth.  There is no sugar coating the shameful situation that the Orangutans are in.

Fact: Orangutans brought with no proper space available for them.

Fact: After quarantine female Amoi had yard access seven weeks. ..Chimps then had to be on lock down in Dayroom.

Fact: After being here eight months both orangutans were given access to the yard. It had been four months since the female had been out. It was the first time, since his arrival eight months ago, that the male Ollie had been out.

Fact: There is still no third space, creating a place for the Orangutans to have daily outdoor access.

When members of the public ask staff about the Orangutans and where is their exhibit, they have no other option than to sell the illusion that has been forced upon them.   At least now, the rotating of the Orangutans into the yard is not a total lie but two days a week is not right.  They are also obligated to say, the Zoo is working on a plan for Triple Grotto.  That plan seems indefinite and that's just not good enough.

I don't know what prompted the Orangutans getting yard access or the people in Triple Grotto, but this all happened days after I sent out some emails.  That said, if connected, this should not happen because a member of the public complains. It should happen because its the right thing to do.

The Zoo Director, Tanya Peterson, should being doing better for our Animal Residents.  

Our Animal Friends deserve better.

At the end of April, the Orangutans will have been here one year.

*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*


Friday, January 3, 2020

Happy New Year! ... Sadly Not at Krefeld Zoo.

I had planned to use my opportunity for extended time at home over this Holiday to finish many posts.  Who knows if I would have been productive by now, but I have certainly been disabled by the tragedy at Krefeld Zoo since the moment I heard about it.

For those who don't know, the Monkey House at Krefeld Zoo in Germany, fell victim to a fire in the early hours of New Years Day.

It was 11:40p here and I was trying to stay awake to see in our new decade.  Thinking of things I needed to accomplish, and of how surreal the year 2020 sounds.  Then I read the news.  First reports that all Residents of the Monkey House had perished.  My insides immediately felt heavy and tears started flowing.  The same feeling would have overtook me had there been a single Soul lost, but the final number of lives lost, is now Thirty.  Thankfully there were two survivors.  

The two Chimpanzees who survived this horror, lost their friend.  Probably watched as he was either burnt alive or succumbed to smoke inhalation.  The family of five Orangutans, included an infant, whose Mother was probably trying to comfort and save her babie.  Two Gorilla's, who lived through being taken from their wild families decades ago, only to die this way.   These are just the Great Apes who lost their Lives.  Dozens of other poor Souls, spent their final moments in fear, trapped in cages, not being able to escape.  The images that I've created in my mind of all these precious Beings desperation to stay alive, has been hard to shake. 

As the minutes ticked on, I read that the possible cause was Fireworks. It was now midnight and several backyards over from my Richmond District home, I can hear, illegal Fireworks being set-off, and see bursts of light from them.  I was so enraged, as I am every July 4th and every New Years Eve that this happens.  I'm not trying to rain on anyone's parade, but they are illegal for a reason.  They are a potential hazard.  In that moment the audacity was too much. For many reasons I am sick of people.  I'm sick of the self-entitled.  People who do whatever they want, with no regard for those around them.  This is another example of that mentality.  The City of San Francisco puts on a display at the waterfront.  Go there.  I mean seriously people don't even have the sense to do this shit at the beach, if they want to be reckless. ... It has been confirmed that Sky Lanterns, illegal in Germany were the cause.

It has also been reported that the Monkey House structure had no Sprinkler System.  It has not been reported Why.  It has not been reported whether not having them went against any EAZA accreditation guidelines, or government ordinances.  I do not know for fact, but would hope our AZA has a guideline for that.  It would seem, any space where there are lives that are confined, should at least have some sort of emergency help system. 

There has been no comment by the EAZA.  The WAZA posted condolences to their Facebook page.  In a search, only one other Zoo (in the world?) posted condolences.  I hope there were others, because its shameful that a community would not have any caring words for their peers and what has befallen on them. 

Lastly I want to include two other tragedies.  Admittedly, I sometimes tend to shut out reading about sad things, because there is so much of it, and sometimes I just can't.  After seeing a sad video, I read only one article about the tragedy last month at African Safari Wildlife Park in Ohio, who had ten of their Residents perish in a barn fire.  I have also, until the last couple days, passed up most of the sad photos of victims from the tragic situation that continues in Australia, where it is now reported that over 500 million Animal lives has been lost.  It being 2020 isn't nearly as surreal as that number of Wildlife lost. 

All documentation of these events are heartbreaking and horrific.  I can't imagine how people are dealing with seeing this first hand, especially those who cared for and knew the captive Animals affected.  To all of them, I am sorry for your loss.  It is heartbreaking from a afar, it would be unbearable to be close to.


*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*