Sunday, April 29, 2018

HOT TOPIC! - Fossa Footage, Jillian's Return and Other AZA/SSP Issues.

9.9.18 ... When I started posting about the Snow Leopard Cubs, I noticed I had this post still in draft.  I thought it had been posted when written 4.29.18 I am posting it now as it was written and you will see in the first paragraph there is a link to a post before it that it was written containing connected information.  Apologies for anyone who read that post and might have been waiting for the additional information.
--------
Ok, getting back on issue track. I finally found the Fossa footage I took last Fall when I went on a Bird Walk that took the group beyond some Employee Only barriers. ... You can read my previous post that I wanted to include the footage in, 
As well view the video, which also contains more recent footage.  .. 9.9.18 Note that the Foosa have been moved from this area.  More on that in an upcoming post regarding the Madagascar project.

I started writing a post about Female Sumatran Tiger Jillian's return to the San Francisco Zoo, since before she got back.  Once I heard she was returning, issues and questions I have had for years about the AZA's SSP (Species Survival Plan) started to surface again.  They have always been there, but certain situations really bring about the questions, *Is the SSP really operating in the best way?  *What really is their end goal with captive breeding?  *Do they over-breed under the guise of Conservation, or mostly for the gate sales that babie Animals bring to the Zoos?  And most important, *Are their guidelines and protocols, in the individual Animals best interests?   

I've talked to alot of people associated with the Zoo Industry about these questions, surprisingly the amount who share the same concerns, has increased in recent times.  That doesn't mean that there aren't a good majority who buy into everything the AZA and Zoos put forth about the SSP.   Quickly, for those who may not be familiar with the SSP, it is part of the AZA (Association of Zoos and Aquariums) that manages the Animal Species that live in Accredited Zoos.  They manage using a Studbooks specific to each Species which contains all the information on every Animal.  That info is used to make breeding recommendations based on Genetic Diversity.  Every year there are meetings to discuss who in each species will be allowed to breed that year.   The goal in short is to maintain a diverse population of all Species.  Its under the guise of Conservation, but what does that mean?  Eventually keeping an extinct in the wild species alive only in captivity, or  sending even more (yes this is happening now) captive born Animals to live in the wild?  I seriously don't think, rather I personally do not believe with the way this cruel world is, any Animals that are under threat from Humans should be put back into the wild.  

As noted I have had some issues with the protocols as dictated.  So I'm just going to mention some of the Animals, and a bit about the issue I have with them in regard to the breeding program.  I'm not making a specific slam against SFZoo for most of what has happened with these Animals, because I've learned, as noted with the SSP breeding program, they seem to dictate what goes on, otherwise they are allegedly threatened with accreditation being pulled or some other repercussion for not playing ball with them.

The first Animals I identified an issue with was the Duikers, who I first met in 2008.  Those poor Duikers. I have posted them about many times, as there have been so many instances of disrespect to them to count. When I first knew the Dukiers, they lived as a close knit Family, Male Erik, Female Lily, and their first (I think) Son Java.  They lived in an area now in shambles, that the Zoo refers to as South Gate.  I called it Hoofstock Alley since there were several Hoofstock living along that path.  So many years, so many disrespects, I hope I can keep it all straight, but in general this is a pretty accurate timeline.  If I get a couple of offspring times mixed up, it doesn't really affect the outcome of the story.  Anyway, after Java was transferred out, they bred again.  It was sometime before Son Houdini was transferred, so the Family was split up and Lily was left alone, while Erik and Houdini were moved to the old Warthog area after the Warthogs both passed away.  I thought this was really cruel because Erik and Lily were a bonded pair, who loved eachother, but because they were still part of breeding program, they didn't want to implant her.  Erik and Houdini weren't at the Warthog area long when the Zoo decided to bring in Peccaries.  So they both got shuffled to the area behind the Eland (now off exhibit Bongos). This was a bad move because as I was told, there was not enough night quarters for both species and a few days after the move, in the middle of winter, with no night quarter of his own, Bubsy the Eland was found dead one morning, allegedly after spending the night in the freezing cold. A casulty of a breeding program in a Zoo that had no place to house a mate and an offspring with no place to go.  Houdini continued to live off exhibit, and soon Erik was put back with Lily to breed again.  I think they had a Daughter (South Gate was closed by this time) and at a certain point they were ripped apart again, sending Erik to the Savannah. After over a year, Lily joined Erik on the Savannah and they were so happy to be together.  Lily got pregnant and they were again ripped apart.  Lily gave birth to Josie and they were in the coral at the side of the Giraffe barn.  Erik would come over and sniff them.  He wanted to be with his Family. It was heartbreaking.  Soon, the moved Lily and Josie back to South Gate.  After another year or so apart, Lily rejoined Erik on the Savannah.  Josie lived alone down at South Gate for too long.  I want to say a year, it may have been more, before she was transferred out.  So let's recap.  Lily and Erik bred four times, bonded to eachother, they were ripped apart four times, and their last three offspring, sat in the Zoo mostly alone because they had no immediate placement. Today Lily and Erik both live at the Savannah, but not together.  She can't be implanted and because of her age she shouldn't be bred, so they can't be in same space.  Sadly, I think they don't even have access to seeing eachother.  That needs to change. 

My second experience was when our Georgie left.  Bali/George was the male Sumatran who was Skylar/Leanne's first mate, the Father of her three Boys.  It has become clear to me that the male Tigers are basically just used as studs and can be transferred out to different Zoos at anytime.  This is wrong. The SSP needs to take a strong look at IVF. They are already doing it with the Wolves, they need to do it with other Species so these Animals can have secure homes. So, for genetic diversity, George (I called him that mostly because I didn't know til later that he had an original name) was sent to Point Defiance Zoo.  Actually a good move for him as he was able to reclaim his given name, Bali, and he would eventually have health issues, that I think would not have been managed as well at SFZoo.  Bali was a great Tiger.  loved by all.  He got along wonderful with our Tony (Male Siberian) and our Padang (Female Sumatran).  I really missed him. 

When the Boys were just over a year old, they were transferred to Akron Zoo, to live as a bachelor group until breeding recommended homes for them were found.  Taymor, Male Sumatran, was transferred to SF to breed with Skylar/Leanne.  Quickly disrespected, his name was changed to Larry.  They were put together and got along great.  When she got pregnant they were separated.  That was in the fall 2012.  Jillian was born Feb 2013. Over the next four plus years, Taymor would live alone.  Zoos will tell you that certain Animals are solitary in the wild.  In my opinion, if an Animal that is solitary in the wild, displays behavior that would indicate it is better with a companion in captivity, then that is what should happen.  Zoos are too wrapped up in handling the behaviors of  Captive Animals as Wild Animals, when really they are someplace in between and adjustments to that should be made.  I'm sure there are those reading this that will say I'm no professional, so I don't know what I'm talking about. Well, it doesn't take being a professional to have compassion.  

So, Jillian. Jillian stayed in SF just past her fourth Birthday.  Why?  I was told from the time she was a year that she was going here, then there, nothing ever materialized.  Why?  Who really knows.  I assume that there was just no place for her.  Which then makes you wonder, what would have happened had Skylar/Leanne had given birth to more than one female Cub.  Where would they all have gone?  SSP gives breeding rec's but they have no idea how many Cubs will be born, so there is no way they can predict that there will be a place for them.  Jillian was popular, she did her job in bringing in tons of people to the Zoo, so I'm sure the AZA was quite happy.  Don't get me wrong, I love her and loved the experience of watching another Cub grow up, that is not what this is about.  This is about what happened to her after.  Not having a place to go for so long was detrimental to her.  She was comfortable in SF, the only home she knew, for four years.  Then she was finally sent to Sacramento Zoo, where she lived alone for a year.  Why was she alone? Where was her genetic match?  She is supposed to be one of the most genetically valuable females in the Sumatran breeding program right now.  She was supposedly sent out as part of the breeding program, yet there was no mate to join her.  She went from living with her Mama, in a house full of Cats to living alone with no other Cats in sight.  By all accounts, Jillian was rarely seen on exhibit, preferring to hide.  When news that she would be coming back surfaced, SacZoo put out a press release, that among other upsetting info, included the heartbreaking note that they had been medicating her to help with her behavior.  I was disgusted.  I assume the SacZoo thought they were doing what was best, and they were advised to do this, but honestly, I don't have much trust in them.  Not too long before that, the SSP made the decision to breed Jillian's Grand Mother, Bahagia, a Senior, with a new young Mate after her life companion, Castro passed away.  Baha had already given many Cubs to the Zoo/SSP/AZA, yet they felt the need to push another pregnancy on her.  The young Male ended up killing her when they were put together. Wrong for the SSP to even suggest this and wrong for SacZoo to go along with it.  Sorry for the digress but when I get going on these Animals stories it all comes flowing in.  

So Jillian is now back in SF.  She quarantined in the Lion House, surrounded by all the Cats she knew, including her Parents.  She has had access to the yard for five weeks now. I've seen her once. She prefers to stay inside. Sad.  That whole situation really seems to have messed her up.   Hopefully in time will settle into being home. Here's my video of her from a couple weeks ago,  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sdhjosAT_HA

Let's talk about Jillian's Mama and Papa.  So while Jillian was away, Sky and Taymor were put together, on SSP breeding recommendation.  They get along great, and seem to love eachother!  They are so happy to be together.  They enjoy each others company.  Sleep side by side.  Its a beautiful thing.  So what happens if Sky gets pregnant?  That's right, they get ripped apart for probably the rest of their lives.  Both could be considered Seniors, probably should not even be in breeding program, but the flip side of that is some twisted shit.  If they weren't in the breeding program and actively being bred, the SSP forbids them to be housed together.  These Animals just can't win.  And it doesn't even make sense.  Since Lions live in a Pride in the wild, they are allowed to stay together in captivity, but because Tigers are considered solitary they can't?  WTH?  Sorry that's just BS.

So yea more BS.  Last fall, I noticed the Female Snow Leopard Niya off exhibit.  After the recent passing of Male Ghurka, I had become concerned that something was wrong with Niya.  Then all of a sudden, we have a new pair and Niya has been moved to the off exhibit FCC (old Feline Conservation Center), never to be seen again. No notice, like with Male Rigel (who has since passed), just off they go, those who love them don't even get notice.  ... So, allegedly the story goes as such.  The SSP told the Zoo they wanted them to remain a breeding facility for Snow Leopards and would be sending them a new pair, and transferring Niya out. WTH?  Are you kidding me.  Niya has lived at the Zoo seven years, and is now considered a Senior, and they want to move her?  This is what I mean about the SSP protocols not being in the Animals best interest.  Thankfully, as I know it, the SFZoo said they had a place for Niya to retire (FCC) and were allowed to keep her here.  Grateful they went to bat for her.  Moving her would have just been cruel.  That said, if they didn't have the extra space and wanted to keep her there in place, would AZA possibly then threaten the Zoo with losing their accreditation or another repercussion to strong arm them?   That is allegedly what they do if Zoos don't comply with what they want. 

Speaking of cruel.  Let's talk about the Male Lion Tailed Macaque, Jesus.  Jesus was left alone when his companion Suana passed away.  Jesus was born at the SFZoo and at thirty-five years old, should have been able to live the rest of his life there.  Well, SSP recommended a place with a few girlfriends, so he was transferred out.  I would have rather seen a Female brought in for him.  Why that couldn't happen, I don't know.  I did hear that allegedly Director Peterson didn't like the Macaques, so that may have played a role in things.  Whatever the reason, none of it is right.  Age should play a part in the game. I just hope he's happy and has Fathered some babies :)

Well with all my side stories this has turned into a novel, I apologize but its all very upsetting to someone who thinks with their heart.  And as usual, I will note, I'm not the only one who feels this way about each of these situations.  I almost always talk about my thoughts with others before I get to putting them to post. My emotion based thinking, is not solitary. 





No comments:

Post a Comment

*Thank you for your comment. All comments are appreciated and I try my best to reply back in a timely manner. Sometimes timely isn't possible, but I will reply to all comments at some point. Please check back.
*If you have a problem commenting, don't see your comment (within 24 hours), or want to contact me for any other reason, please use the about.me link on the sidebar.
*You can be a Voice for the SFZoo Animals by Contacting the San Francisco Zoo Director Tanya Peterson at tanyap@sfzoo.org
*Thank You for taking the time to read about things that matter to me.