Friday, October 26, 2018

News Flash! Cincinnati Zoo Sues Gorilla Foundation For Custody of Gorilla Ndume

I woke up today to this news.  It has hit many media sources, this is the article I read first.  
It contains the Court Document, so make sure to click on that link in the article.


This is upsetting.  Most of us who have followed Ndume's plight (I've posted about it several times), have known this might be a probable situation.  The people who I discuss this with most are a handful of former Gorilla Foundation caregivers.  I grew up following Koko's story, and loving her. Over the past decade since I've become more involved with the SFZoo Animals, I have been uncomfortable with Koko's life and living situation.  A few years ago I read about the other Gorilla there, Ndume.  Like Koko's, a sad life there for a Great Ape.  When Koko passed, I joined and took an active role in the crusade to get Ndume moved out of there. 

There's alot to be angry about with the situation that has resulted in this lawsuit.   Obviously the main issue of The Gorilla Foundation (TGF) not abiding by the agreement.  For me the main issue is still the isolation, which Cincinnati Zoo (CZ) references throughout the court document.  CZ and AZA/SSP (Association of Zoos and Aquariums/Species Survival Plan) have known for decades that Ndume did not live in same enclosure with Koko and they chose to leave him there.  Now they are using that basically as the basis of their argument, with Ron Evans from CZ quoting Gorillas need for "social interaction". I'm not trying to be against them, because of course I believe he should be transferred back there, but I have to state the obvious, CZ and AZA/SSP have basically dug themselves this hole and by proxy the innocent Ndume, by abandoning him there for at minimum 20 yrs more than necessary per the original reason for sending him there, which was to breed with Koko.  He has been left there for 27 years.  Not two years, not seven years, not fifteen, not twenty, 27 years!  Alone. They are the ones who have set this scene.  

How many times other than the one a few years ago with the photo op with Koko,  did either CZ and/or the AZA/SSP visit TGF to check on Ndume?  My sources can only reference the one time in all those years.  Even if more, I highly doubt it was the twice a year stated in those documents.  I assume neither CZ or AZA/SSP are unaware as they are supposed to be made up of the highly regarded professionals in their fields, so they also had to know that TGF's whole project had become fantasy in recent years if not earlier.  The argument that Koko needed companionship, in my opinion is not valid.  As I understand it, Koko was never allowed to co-habitate with other Gorillas.  Random encounters over the years, but no consistent daily interaction.  Koko was raised as a Human and had no need for Gorilla companionship.  This is allegedly and likely why she wasn't interested in breeding or being with other Gorillas.  Penny ruined Koko's life by denying her a Gorilla Family.  There is no way "professionals" from CZ and AZA/SSP didn't get that, at least in the past decade plus. Bottom line CZ and AZA/SSP abandoned Ndume and because of that TGF feels entitled to keep him.  If it was not for the facts, That Penny and Ron are seemingly and allegedly unfit to care for any Gorilla, That there are no other Gorillas for companionship, and That by all accounts the enclosures are in need of updates, considering the length of time Ndume has lived there (more than half his life) and his age, I would support leaving him there, BUT those key issues are the reason he should be transferred.  He needs to be with other Gorillas.  

This is a mess, and make no mistake poor Ndume is the casualty of all parties, CZ, AZA/SSP and TGF's negligence in providing him the proper compassion and attention for 27 years.   In my opinion all parties did what was self-serving, CZ and AZA/SSP had no use for him in their system, so ignored him for decades and TGF needed a faux companion for their fantasy spin on Koko's life to continue garnering donations.  Ndume has paid the price and will continue to.  

I hope this is sorted out soon, without any further drama.  I pray Ndume will remain safe though this battle, as I have heard from two sources that they would fear for Ndume's life in a custody battle and here we now are. 

*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:
https://iamnotananteater.blogspot.com/2018/09/my-zoo-status.html

Sunday, October 14, 2018

Survey and Quotes - What Other's Would Like To See Done At The SFZoo

In my previous post, I wrote about what I would want to see done at the Zoo.   The catalyst for posting those thoughts was hearing about yet another project that once again in my opinion did not support my feelings that the Zoo should Take Care At Home, meaning, do what's best for the Animals that already live there. I decided to take a poll.  Without going into detail about the new project, I asked people in my circle what they would want to see done at the Zoo.  Below are quotes from those I asked.  Some who work at the Zoo, some who used to.  Some who visit randomly, some who are Members.  Its been six months, so if anyone has additional thoughts to add, please contact me or add them via the survey. 

I am interested in hearing how others would answer, so please take (and share) my short Survey.  Five questions total, three are optional.  The Survey is completely Anonymous!  So, if you work at the Zoo and want to express yourself, you can do so confidently.  If you want your voice to be heard, I'd like to post your answers in an update of this post.  If you prefer not to have them public, write Private in the comment box for that question.  

What Projects Would You Like To See At The San Francisco Zoo?

"Building/Upgrading exhibits for Senior Residents. Constructing for Animals in behind the scenes holdings, so public can see them and they can get added Enrichment by people watching."

"Improve Bear and Cat Habitats, (and Chimps pending size of new areas).  They need more space and more naturalistic.  Combine some areas, or build new in undeveloped areas of the Zoo." 

"Conservation projects.  I'd like to see SFZoo as a Global Awareness Advocate like San Diego, and the Bronx Zoo.  I'm ashamed our big City Zoo isn't a prominent figure in Conservation, like SDZ and BZ.  ... Exhibit Updates."

"My big number one is signage: a single uniform style. includes: clear directional signs, eg, the way out of the parking lot. intelligent animal descriptions including age of species. taxonomy charts my group, eg, primates, carnivores. make the Zoo's organization by group transparent. AND a sign telling people where to exit from parkinglot!!! ... more art. more history, eg vintage engravings by species classifiers. ... non-reflective glass. ... plastic casts of skulls, as at grizzly bears. ... flight space for all birds, eg rebuild the short string & give the kookaburras a sunny home. ... swing space for siamangs. ... redesign Insect House as per Patrick's needs. ... BATS!!! ... reclaim that body of water from the duck-weed. ... restore the Wetlands — this will never happen, merely a fantasy!"

"Education.  More specific Education about SFZoo Animals.  Stronger Education about Wild Animals in Crisis." 

"Upgrade All, including Mothers Building"

"All for the Animals."

"After Update all, bring in Big Animals."

"Upgrades for all.  Build area to Rescue Lab Chimps. 200 are sitting in holding with no place to go."

"New Gorilla Habitat with and pool and more Enrichment.  Swinging and Climbing Equipment and space. ... Waste of money on new exhibit. They should turn down the money."

"Upgrade all. . Tram" 

"Take care of old exhibits and Animals first.  More Enrichment for the Animals."

"Upgrades to the Animals Exhibits , that Benefit the Animals!"

Thank you to everyone who gave me answers.

*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:



What I'd Like To See Done At The San Francisco Zoo

For almost a decade now I have had ideas about what I'd like to see at the Zoo.  As I became more aware and endeared to the Animals as individuals, those thoughts grew and became endless.  I have kept notes on each thought, most that involve the Animals and really need no notes as they loop through my mind constantly.  

The catalyst for this post is an upcoming project, that in my opinion should not be happening at this time, as there are in-need projects that are ignored.  My list here will mostly highlight projects I feel are in-need, with some other ideas.  It's not my complete list, although I may ramble on, and it may seem like it is!

There's been several projects over the past five or so years that have taken priority over those in-need.  Each time one came about, my thoughts went to three Animals.   The Chimps, who waited over thirty years to get any updates to their home.  They waited to the point where they were in jeopardy of being kicked out by the Zoo Director Tanya Peterson.  I Roared as loud as possible for them and with KGO-TV's help, created public outrage, and thankfully these Friends never knew what was happening.  Not only a callous decision, they could have lost their lives in a move like that.  Wishbone the Andean Bear, did lose his life to being forced to live exclusively on concrete.  I Roared for him, but never reached the right people.  The Zoo knew, the Rec and Park knew, the Donors knew,  no one cared to do the right thing for him.   Falcor the Komodo Dragon, who was stuck living in a terrarium for years.  Again everyone knew and no one cared. The Zoo will say timing coincided with health issues.  I call BS on that.  He was supposed to get a new home within a year/half of arrival.  His health issues didn't start til after that time frame.  If he had a proper home, his post-op rehabilitation would have been optimum and he'd probably be more advanced in his recovery than he is.  These three cases have broken my heart many times over.  Animals in-need and yet those able to help with funding ignored them.

Wishy passed away in 2010.  Since then, so many projects came before the Chimps and Falcor.  The Playground, Sculpture Garden, Tiki Hut, Tropical Aviary Renovation, Red Pandas, Wolverines, Wolves, Sifaka, New Flamingo Fencing, Fragrance Garden.  Some of these projects had money locked, which means donations specifically for these projects.  Four included building for new Animals, while those already living at the Zoo were in-need.  

So, What would I do at the Zoo?  A whole lot that's not being done.  These are the projects that I think are in-need and should be a priority over anything else, except for Animals in-need of rescuing, like our Black Bear Cubs or our Sea Lions and Grizzly Girls before them. 

Number one priority for me is Zoo-wide upgrade to barriers.  Specifically at Black Bears, Grizzly, Hippo, and Black Rhino.  If they don't want to put up glass everywhere, at the very least there needs to be a deterrent much like at the male Anteater exhibit.  A jagged barrier that would prevent people from sitting on/over, or standing on barrier railings.  Signs not to do so at every barrier, code-red or not.  Signs at the Entrance. The signs about not crossing barriers are useless.  Keeping the Animals safe, and the Human offenders by proxy should be priority.

I'd like to see Aviaries built for the Birds that live in cages across from the Chimps and the one behind the old Komodo area.  The open field between the Wrinkled Hornbill Aviary and the Food Depot is an obvious location.  Even using that Depot area which is unnecessary for food and then for entertainment during their Zootoberfest.  In my opinion all Events should take place at the Playfield area.  That Depot area, which many years ago was the site of Monkey Island, should be used for Animals.  There is also a huge unused area behind it.  Once those cages are empty, an Aviary could be built there.

I'd like to see the area for the Sloth expanded.  There is no reason the area in the Tropical Building that houses the Sloth is so small and houses four Animals.  The seating to the side should be done away with and the area expanded. As well, an appropriate area for the second Sloth that has been moved from the Tropical Building to the Lion House and to a reduced space.  That terrarium is not a habitat.

I'd like to see the closed areas opened.  There are too many areas closed and have been for too long.  Not only do people not like it, there are Animals that could use the space, and Animals living there that should be viewable.   

First, behind that south east fencing that starts at Hippo and goes toward Grizzlies is an area called South Gate.  This area used to house several species of hoofstock.  It was closed many years ago, as I understand originally because they didn't want to spend time keeping it up.  That proved to be true as I saw the condition it was in last fall, and was almost shocked. I was also shocked and disgusted to see two of the Peccaries living back there, among the ruins of downed fencing, overgrowth, and just plain devastation of once what was a lovely area.  I thought I wrote a post about it with photos, but it didn't come up in a search.  Will link here later if I find it.

So, I'd like to see South Gate re-opened.  They could move the Bongo there.  They could create the extra Peccary habitat that is needed.  They could move the Guanacos from the Puente there.  The Guanacos are on rotation.  The male is living alone, and is rotated a few days a week out of a small holding area to the Puente yard.  He is rotated with the female and their daughter.  These Animals need their own appropriate sized space.  Creating one side by side in South Gate would give them visible access if they wanted.  There is also space for future hoofstock or part of my Rhino idea below.

Next, and even more so now with some Monkey species living there after losing their homes to the new project, the Feline Conservation Center needs to reopen.  An area closed in 2008, in the wake of the Tiger Escape, but allegedly closed for not being handicap accessible.   For those who don't know, the FCC opened in the 80s.  A very cool and secluded area for Medium and Small Cats.  I always liked visiting this area, seeing Sabrina the Black Leopard, who I had visited for so many years, even when she sadly still lived in a cage before FCC opened.  The FCC had maybe half dozen aviary style enclosures. Too small really to be habitats for Leopards, the Snows lived there too, but decent for the Ocelots, and the Fishing Cats.  I remember watching the Fishing Cat kittens out in the open with a Keeper learning to fish.   

There was a time in 2010 when all Cats were either moved down to the Main Zoo or shipped out (Ocelots).  It became an active home when Senior male Snow Leopard Rigel moved there to "retire" as the Zoo was bringing in a male that was born there to be the new breeding companion of Niya.  He passed away, and Niya was then retired to FCC, while the Zoo brought in our current pair.  The FCC now is home to more Animals than it has room for.  In addition to Niya, Raj the father of our Snow Cubs also lives there.  I'm actually happy that Niya now has company, so that didn't work out too bad.  When the Zoo decided it just had to have a male Andean Condor after allegedly refusing to send the female back to her original home Zoo, they both have now been living there for a couple years.  The Zoo had no space for two Condors on exhibit.  Thankfully, the Fossa have now also moved to FCC.  None of these Animals co-habitate, so that is already six aviaries in use.  With the displacement of Monkeys from the Primate Center (read future post about Madagascar project)  allegedly some aviaries were split in two, to accommodate the Howler and soon Colobus Monkeys.

My point about reopening FCC is that there are so many Animals there now, they should be able to be viewed.  Especially the Monkeys that will not be on exhibit during the future construction.  This should have happened long ago and now, it definitely should have been part of the deal prior to the new project breaking ground.  In my opinion that deal should have called for construction of new Monkey enclosures in exchange for displacing from current ones.

Other things I'd like to see as a secondary priority, exhibit upgrades and additional space for Animals who could use it.  

The Animals at the Farm could use some additional rotating spaces.  There had been talk of re-purposing the old Duck pond but nothing has happened.  There are a couple other surrounding areas that could be used as well.  The Cow spends half his day isolated in a back coral.  The San Clemente Goats are contained in one area all day.  The Farm needs at least two additional areas.

Improvements to any Enclosure that is in-need. Some things simple, like adding landscaping to the Gorillas so at least half of their contact window is level with Humans.  They shouldn't be directly looked down on.  Some full on renovations, like new floor to ceiling glass barriers at Cat grotto, allowing for moats to be filled in and topical areas extended by ten plus feet.

I would like to see both Rhinos in better habitats.   I've always hated the Black Rhino enclosure front and back configuration.  Poor Elly the female (passed now) was banished to the back for years.  This exhibit should have had side by side areas so both Animals had equal living situations. Expanding Black Rhino into Bongo area would allow for the back part of Black Rhino to be used for Hippo.  Hippo pool should be glassed in, taking away all the heavy wiring that he constantly gnaws on and eliminating the issue of people hanging over the barrier. 

I would like to see the Asian Rhino have an expansion or new enclosure and a companion.  At the San Francisco Zoo.  It is possible.  There is space.  Expand into the adjacent empty exhibit or build a new one in the old Black Rhino enclosure and the area adjacent to that. That would provide so much room. This exhibit sits along the path going west of the Grizzly Bears, behind the fenced off area across from the lake.  That area is huge, and could accommodate not only an area big enough for two Asian Rhinos, but for a mirror enclosure to the Grizzly Gulch, which could house the Black Bears in the future, allowing the Black Bears and the Grizzlies to rotate.  The Grizzlies have running water in the Gulch so there should be no reason an awesome new pool for Asian Rhino could not be built.  I want to note that Gauhati the Asian Rhino loves his pool, and the waterfall has not been working allegedly for near a year.  Much like the six months that the Lion House had no heat, this is wrong. While not as necessary as heat obviously, its still something that should have been fixed promptly.

Anyway, those are just a short list of things I can think of that should be done for the Animals currently living at the Zoo, before bringing in any news ones and building homes for them, unless they are in-need rescues.  

All the Animals living at the Zoo deserve appropriate habitats.  The Zoo needs to provide that, without entertaining ideas of shipping them out, like they tried to do with the Chimps and have now done with three species living in the Primate Center.  Take Care At Home!

Something non-Animal related, there is an effort by a Historian to repair the Mother's Building.  When this is done, it would be a wonderful place for a History Center.

This post is one in a series of three.  See next two posts for subject matter in full.  Thank you.

*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:
https://iamnotananteater.blogspot.com/2018/09/my-zoo-status.html



HOT TOPICS! - List by Year and Other Blog Links

(Re-positioning this upcoming post for flow)

You can search HOT TOPICS!  in upper left corner of blog.   I'm still notating blog posts as HOT TOPICS! for easy Issues of Interest reference, so will update with the HOT TOPICS! list soon. 

You can also view my other previous blogs that contain Issues of Interest.

2011 - Andean Bears Wishbone and Annie lived most of their life exclusively on concrete.  Annie passed before my crusade.  One of the health issues that caused her passing was alleged hip and leg issues, preventing her from walking.  I crusaded for Wishbone to have grass patches added to his home.  Read more about my efforts.  The Zoo Management and Society Members FAILED him.  He passed away with full mental capacity.  Euthanized because he couldn't walk.  He literally pounded his bones to his death.  No One Cared this was happening.   http://projectgetwishbonegrass.blogspot.com/

2011 -  In putting together this list I end up glancing at past posts.  So many years later and same BS going on.  I just don't understand. <Sigh>  That said, I was told by people who had tried to get change at the Zoo in the 80s and another group in the 90s, no one with authority (read The City of San Francisco) would listen. 

This last post from 2012 caught my eye, as there was a text highlighting issue, which I again just tried to fix.  It mentions Wishbones plight, and also a couple quotes from my blog that appeared in a news article.  These quotes are still relevant and key to a near future blog post.  Keep in mind this was seven years ago and nothing has changed, especially in this regard. 

"So, new animals and humans, get bright, shiny, new and modern areas, while current animals continue to live status quo. I personally can not imagine being someone of authority in the Zoological Society and being able to sleep at night knowing I was forging ahead with plans that did not include helping the animals that already live there, before anything else," wrote a female blogger...

I continued to note,.. I will say that, Animal Care VP David Bocian who is the subject of this article, has been at the Zoo well over a year, and for someone being touted as caring about the Animals, how could he (along with Director Tanya Peterson, Curators Corinne MacDonald and Debra Marrin, as well members of the San Francisco Zoological Society and anyone else who holds authority there) let Wishbone live on concrete with known back/bone/joint issues, letting him to eventually die from those issues? 
Post in full:

2013/2015 -  I started this blog to post short snips, good and of issue.  It actually worked til I started to let go of posting every little thing.  Time was limited and the longer posts to this blog were energy and emotion draining.  I liked this Commentary style and will leave a Coming Soon post as I think I may want to get back to this style at some point.  Take a scan through and you will find much Zoo Friend cuteness, all the Birthdays when I was still noting each one, ...

HOT TOPICS! - Coming Soon!
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011




Saturday, October 6, 2018

Barrier Breaching No Big Deal - I Just Don't Understand

So yeah, this exhausting subject again.  I actually didn't plan on writing about this again, as I've pretty much exhausted all that I can do to document and bring awareness to this issue.  As well, if you've been following my recent posts, you may have noticed that I put a few posts in draft, as I am wrapping up all in progress posts and wanted to end this round with a certain flow and finale.  Unfortunately the other day, the following happened, and I felt I must document it.  As my title states, I just don't understand.  I don't understand the Zoo's and the AZA's position of ignorance at what I consider a serious issue.

As I walked up towards Hippo and Black Rhino, two women each had a kid sitting over the Hippo barrier.  I didn't get a photo in time, but as I looked ahead, another had their kid over the Rhino barrier.


After I took this photo, Big Cat Keeper Andrew came walking by.  I called his attention to the offense, and he said he'd be back.  This was surprising as most Keepers will say something if you point this out.  I think its negligent that he did not immediately say something.  I guess playing with the photos on the cat grotto windows was more important than the life of the Rhino or the kid.  All it takes is a split second for an accident to happen and the kid falls into the enclosure and the Rhino comes over and makes contact, whether threatening or not.  Rhinos are Code-Red Animals, and if contact is made between a Code-Red Animal and a Human, the protocol is shoot to kill.  I complain about management having their priorities messed up, but I'm very disappointed when a member of the Keeper staff, doesn't put Animal Safety first. 

By the time Andrew wandered back, of course that lady had taken her kid down.  Less than ten minutes later, this guy had his kid up there.  That's four kids over barriers in about fifteen minutes.  Fifteen minutes of one day, at one area.  The Zoo is open 420 minutes everyday, with multiple barriers being breached.


This Rhino exhibit, Hippo and Bears, are the most abused barriers.  Its a continuous stream of people hanging their kids over and something I've written about for over seven years now.  Still the Zoo Management does nothing to deter this behavior.  There is no verbal guidelines for this, and there is minimal signage, something else I've written about to an exhausting level.  

The Zoo has three different signs about barriers.  Two make reference to crossing, one to standing/sitting.  Curiously, for something so potentially tragic, all are smaller than most other signs at the Zoo.  In the first photo on this post, you can see one of the ones about crossing the barrier.  The woman has her kid over the barrier right in front of the sign.  Its the stupidest sign.  I asked people once how they interpreted it and one person said they thought it meant no peeing in the exhibit.  

Here's the one sign that specifically says not to stand/sit on barrier.  You can see the pathetic size of it.  Curiously, this sign appears in only a few places.  At Bears, for as long as that barrier is, I think there is only one of these signs.  Seven inches, in probably over a hundred feet of barrier.  I don't think this sign is even at Rhinos.  BUT, it is at Sikafa???  Don't get me wrong, I think it should be a Zoo-wide rule for people not to be on or over any barriers, but for the sake of comparison, this is an Animal that is fenced in and not Code-Red.  Not sure what that's about, but its obviously a head shaker.  ... THIS sign should be huge and at the entrance of the Zoo, as well as at least every ten feet of every exhibit barrier. 


Sifaka exhibit

You can search this blog for keywords, barriers and signage and come up with lots of entries.  Many photos of signs of curious size, in regard to the nature of the message.  Last week these new signs appeared for the event Zootoberfest.  Gotta make sure everyone knows all there is about the Hay Maze, including do's and don'ts, but they can't tell people in a larger way not to hang over barriers?  I think there are more signs in this one Maze area than all of the barrier signs on Code-Red Animals.  Keep in mind the size of that one sign as you see the size of these signs.  Mind boggling. 

Nice big and fancy on wood!  
approx 3x5 
approx 2x8 
Sandwich board in path
Rules on Stand at entrance of Maze.
approx 8x11, at least three times 
the size of rules about barrier breaching.

There was also two huge banners about 2.5 x 5.5 feet attached to the hay bales. So that's four huge signs, one sandwich board, and a stand-up rules sign.  Six for this one non-Animal area and I think the tally at Code-Red Animal areas is, three at Bears, two at Rhino and one at Hippo. ... Also this new one that is at least eight times the size of the barrier sign, is on a cover of pipes.  Gotta make sure they toss about their Conservation efforts, especially while people are hanging over the barriers putting Animals lives at risk and Ducks are playing Russian Roulette with their lives flying into windows at Flamingos. Good Grief , its all so Shameful. 


I apologize for the quality off the photos on this post.  I didn't have time to download them to computer so just took pix of my camera display.

Additional update:  Still no decals on the Flamingo windows.  Two weeks now since it was called to Zoo's attention verbally by several people, in writing and on this blog.


*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Blogger's Statement
"Personal Opinions and Facts presented publicly are Not against the law or any rules. ... Censorship and Retaliation Actions in an attempt at Suppression are frowned upon by Healthy Societies."
For Full Statement see this post:
https://iamnotananteater.blogspot.com/2018/09/my-zoo-status.html